“Is Democracy Still Alive? An Examination of Students’ Protests in Bangladesh.”

Read Time: 4 minutes

In recent weeks, Bangladesh has been the epicenter of a significant socio-political upheaval, driven by student protests against a controversial quota system for government jobs. These protests have not only highlighted issues of governance and democracy but have also brought to light severe human rights violations, including police brutality and extrajudicial killings. This blog post delves into the multifaceted nature of these protests, their impact on Bangladesh’s democratic process, and the broader implications for human rights in the country.

Background of the Protests

The protests were ignited by a High Court decision to reinstate a quota system that reserves 30% of government jobs for descendants of veterans from Bangladesh’s 1971 war of independence[1]. This decision reversed a 2018 ruling that had abolished the quota following similar protests. Students and young professionals argue that the system is discriminatory and perpetuates inequality, as it favors a specific group aligned with the ruling party, the Awami League[5][7].

Escalation of Violence and Human Rights Violations

The protests, initially peaceful, quickly escalated into violent confrontations between students and security forces. Reports indicate that nearly 650 people have been killed in the unrest, with hundreds more injured[2][3]. The violence peaked between July 16 and August 11, 2024, coinciding with the resignation of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina[2]. The United Nations and human rights organizations have called for impartial investigations into allegations of extrajudicial killings, arbitrary arrests, and torture by security forces[2][3][5].

Police Brutality and Extrajudicial Killings

The response of law enforcement to the protests has been widely criticized for its brutality. Security forces, including the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB) and Border Guards Bangladesh (BGB), have been accused of using excessive force, including live ammunition, against unarmed protesters[5][6]. One of the most egregious incidents involved the shooting of Abu Sayed, a student leader, which was captured on video and sparked further outrage[1][5]. The UN report highlights numerous instances of unnecessary and disproportionate force, calling for accountability and reform within the security apparatus[3].

Impact on Freedom of Expression and Assembly

The government’s response also included severe restrictions on freedom of expression and assembly. Internet shutdowns and curfews were imposed to curb the spread of protests, significantly hindering communication and mobilization efforts[6][7]. These measures have been criticized as attempts to stifle dissent and control the narrative, further eroding trust in the government[5].

Political Repercussions and Democratic Challenges

The student protests have had profound political repercussions, culminating in the resignation of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina after 15 years in power[1][6]. Her departure marks a significant shift in Bangladesh’s political landscape, with Nobel Laureate Muhammad Yunus appointed as the head of a caretaker government[2]. This transition presents both opportunities and challenges for Bangladesh’s democratic process.

Challenges to Democratic Governance

The protests have exposed deep-seated issues within Bangladesh’s democratic framework. The quota system, seen as a tool for political patronage, is emblematic of broader governance challenges, including corruption and lack of transparency[4][7]. The government’s heavy-handed response to the protests has further undermined democratic institutions and processes, raising concerns about the future of democracy in Bangladesh[5][6].

Opportunities for Reform

Despite these challenges, the current political transition offers a unique opportunity for reform. Student leaders and civil society groups are advocating for comprehensive changes to ensure greater accountability, transparency, and inclusivity in governance[1][2]. The interim government, led by Yunus, has pledged to uphold democratic principles and address the root causes of the unrest, including the controversial quota system[2][3].

Broader Implications for Human Rights

The recent protests have also highlighted significant human rights concerns in Bangladesh. The use of force against protesters, restrictions on freedoms, and reports of torture and ill-treatment underscore the urgent need for reform in the country’s human rights practices[3][5].

International Response and Pressure

The international community has expressed concern over the human rights situation in Bangladesh, with calls for independent investigations and accountability for those responsible for violations[5][6]. Human rights organizations, including Amnesty International, have urged the Bangladeshi government to end the crackdown on protesters and uphold its human rights obligations[5].

Path Forward for Human Rights Advocacy

Moving forward, sustained advocacy and pressure from both domestic and international actors will be crucial in ensuring that human rights are prioritized in Bangladesh’s political transition. This includes addressing systemic issues within law enforcement, protecting freedoms of expression and assembly, and ensuring justice for victims of violence[2][3].

Conclusion

The recent student protests in Bangladesh have been a catalyst for significant political and social change. While they have highlighted critical issues within the country’s democratic and human rights frameworks, they also present an opportunity for meaningful reform. As Bangladesh navigates this period of transition, the resilience and determination of its youth and civil society will be instrumental in shaping a more democratic and just future. The international community’s support and vigilance will also be crucial in ensuring that Bangladesh remains on a path toward genuine democratic governance and respect for human rights.

Citations

[1] https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2024/8/5/the-victory-of-bangladeshs-student-movement-should-not-surprise-anyone
[2] https://www.thehindu.com/news/international/nearly-650-people-killed-in-recent-spate-of-violence-in-bangladesh-un-report/article68535793.ece
[3] https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2024-08/OHCHR-Preliminary-Analysis-of-Recent-Protests-and-Unrest-in-Bangladesh-16082024_2.pdf
[4] https://www.usip.org/publications/2024/07/whats-behind-bangladeshs-student-protests
[5] https://amnesty.ca/urgent-actions/bangladesh-end-brutal-crackdown-on-protestors/
[6] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/longform/2024/8/7/how-bangladeshs-gen-z-protests-brought-down-pm-sheikh-hasina
[7] https://www.asiapacific.ca/publication/explainer-whats-behind-bangladeshs-deadly-protests
[8] https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/daily-review-bangladesh-student-protests/